We liked the Kybrow Pencil's smooth texture and appreciated that the sturdy tip didn't break during our tests. Also, some color transferred onto her fingers when she ran them over her brows. The pigment showed up well on our tester's skin, but the shade range is somewhat limiting. This product has a slightly dry consistency, and the tip broke a couple of times during our testing. Juvia's Place I Sculpt, I Shade Brow Pencil Though we appreciate the affordable price, the intense pigment made it a little hard to create natural-looking strokes, and we wish it came in a few more dark shades. We also tried L'Oréal's Brow Stylist Definer, which has a nice consistency, a retractable precision tip, and a built-in spoolie. Other Options We Tested L'Oréal Brow Stylist Definer Those with the highest scores were ultimately selected for this roundup. Each product was given a score from one to five based on texture, feel, pigment, shade range, wear, and staying power. Next, they tried out the brow pencils to see how well they actually performed. Our testers inspected various design aspects, including the shape, tip, size, sharpening requirements, and notable features. Our beauty editors took their time researching the best brow pencils on the market and selected nearly 40 to try in The Lab, our Manhattan product-testing facility. Our tester noted its creamy, pigmented texture makes application a cinch. For a more affordable pick, consider e.l.f. Our best overall pick is Charlotte Tilbury's Brow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil, a highly pigmented formula that our tester said glides on silky smooth in one stroke.

Shades: 8 | Waterproof: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes Available in eight true-to-tone shades that promise 16 hours of waterproof wear, we really have no complaints about this product. It's also refillable-kind of like a mechanical pencil-so you can cut down on your waste. The dual-ended design has an attached spoolie to help with blending, fluffing, and shaping. Our tester said the creamy texture goes on smoothly without dragging, and the sturdy point resists breaking and smooshing. You can use it to fill in sparse brows or create a structured shape. Boasting a thin, angled tip, this pencil is perfect for precision application. The formula has a matte finish, so it looks natural and blends in with your real hairs. Not only that, but she was able to draw on realistic-looking hairs in a single stroke-no layering needed. Our tester used the natural black shade and loved how the highly pigmented color showed up clearly without being too stark or overwhelming. From transparent formulations that make the brushed-up brow vibe easier to achieve to the most natural-looking colours to fill in any gaps, keep scrolling to see the best eyebrow products worth spending your money on.After trying dozens of products firsthand, Charlotte Tilbury's Brow Cheat was our favorite. I spoke to some brow-blessed influencers to find out which eyebrow products they genuinely love to use. With pencils and brushes and pens and gels and pomades all at our disposal, finding the best eyebrow products for you is no small feat, which is why I've called in some reinforcements. Then, of course, there are products to consider. But as I've already noted, it's all too easy to make a mess of them-just one pluck can be the difference between perfectly symmetrical and mismatched brows.

Since we still find ourselves donning masks for much of the time, with our eyes and brows serving as our most prominent beauty markers, never before has shaping, sculpting, and filling our eyebrows been such a priority. They're the feature that helps to define the face but also the most challenging to get right.

Elf brow pencil